The Best Switch Games of All Time: Why Nintendo’s Hits Are More Divisive Than You Think

Let’s get real: everyone claims to know the best Switch games of all time, but the truth is, the debate is hotter than ever in 2025. With the Nintendo Switch’s library now bursting at the seams, picking the greatest hits isn’t just about nostalgia or sales numbers—it’s about what actually matters to players today. Are you ready to challenge your own favorites? Prepare to be surprised, maybe even outraged, as we break down the best Switch games of all time and why some of your beloved classics might not deserve the hype.

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild—Masterpiece or Overrated?

Breath of the Wild is the game that launched a thousand think pieces. Critics and fans alike have called it the best Switch game ever, and for good reason: its sprawling, open-world Hyrule redefined what adventure games could be. The freedom to climb anything, experiment with physics, and tackle shrines in any order is still unmatched. But let’s be honest—some players find its lack of traditional dungeons and breakable weapons downright infuriating. While it’s a must-play, it’s not the flawless gem everyone pretends it is. Want to see what the fuss is about? Check out Nintendo’s official page for more details here.

Animal Crossing: New Horizons—Chill Vibes or Boring Grind?

Animal Crossing: New Horizons took the world by storm in 2020, becoming the ultimate pandemic escape. Its cute graphics, endless customization, and real-time seasons made it a social phenomenon. But here’s the controversy: is it actually fun, or just a glorified chore simulator? For every player who loves designing their island and trading turnips, there’s another who bounced off the repetitive daily tasks. Still, its cultural impact is undeniable, and it remains a top seller on the Switch. Explore more about its updates and community here.

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate—The Fighter to End All Fighters?

No list of the best Switch games of all time is complete without Super Smash Bros. Ultimate. With a jaw-dropping roster of over 80 fighters, it’s a celebration of gaming history. Competitive players swear by its deep mechanics, while casuals love the chaos of four-player brawls. Yet, some argue the game is too bloated, with balance issues and a steep learning curve for newcomers. Whether you’re a die-hard or a button-masher, Smash Bros. Ultimate is the ultimate party game, but it’s not without its flaws. Learn more about the game and its updates here.

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe—Timeless Fun or Safe Rehash?

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe is the best-selling Switch game for a reason: it’s pure, unfiltered fun. The tracks are inventive, the controls are tight, and the online play keeps the competition fierce. But let’s not ignore the elephant in the room—this is a Wii U port with extra content. While new players are thrilled, longtime fans are still waiting for a true Mario Kart 9. Is Deluxe the pinnacle of kart racing, or just Nintendo playing it safe? Check out the official Mario Kart site here.

The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom—Sequel Perfection or More of the Same?

When Tears of the Kingdom dropped, expectations were sky-high. The sequel expands on Breath of the Wild’s formula with new powers, sky islands, and deeper lore. Fans rave about the creativity and freedom, but some critics say it’s just more of the same. Does it surpass its predecessor, or is it riding on the coattails of past glory? The debate rages on, but there’s no denying its place among the best Switch games of all time. For a deep dive into its features, visit Nintendo’s official site here.

Fire Emblem: Three Houses—Strategy Gold or Anime Overload?

Fire Emblem: Three Houses brought tactical RPGs to the mainstream Switch audience. Its branching storylines, character relationships, and deep combat system are a dream for strategy fans. However, some players complain about the heavy anime influence and the overwhelming amount of dialogue. Is it a modern classic, or just a niche hit that got lucky? The answer depends on how much you love micromanaging your army and navigating high school drama. Discover more about the game here.

Kirby and the Forgotten Land—Platforming Revolution or Just Cute?

Kirby and the Forgotten Land surprised everyone by taking the pink puffball into full 3D. The game’s inventive levels, clever use of Kirby’s copy abilities, and charming co-op mode have earned it rave reviews. But let’s be real—some critics argue it’s too easy and leans too heavily on cuteness over challenge. Is it truly one of the best Switch games of all time, or is it just a delightful diversion? Learn more from Nintendo’s Kirby page here.

Xenoblade Chronicles 3—Epic RPG or Overwhelming Slog?

If you love massive worlds and complex stories, Xenoblade Chronicles 3 is the Switch game for you. It offers hundreds of hours of exploration, tactical combat, and emotional storytelling. But this isn’t a game for everyone. The sheer scale can be daunting, and the anime tropes might not appeal to all. Still, for RPG fans, it’s a high point in the Switch library. Want to see more? Check out the official Xenoblade Chronicles page here.

Super Mario Odyssey—Platforming Genius or Too Easy?

Super Mario Odyssey is often hailed as the best 3D Mario game since Galaxy. Its globe-trotting adventure, inventive power-ups, and sandbox design make it a joy to play. But some longtime fans argue it’s too forgiving, with an abundance of Power Moons and little real challenge. Is Odyssey a masterpiece, or has Mario lost his edge? One thing’s certain: it’s a must-own for any Switch owner. Find out more at Nintendo’s official Odyssey page here.

Honorable Mentions That Deserve the Spotlight

Let’s not forget some of the more divisive or overlooked gems. Astral Chain is a PlatinumGames action title that’s as stylish as it is chaotic, but its unique combat system isn’t for everyone. Metroid Prime Remastered brings a classic to modern audiences, but some fans say it’s just nostalgia in HD. Animal Crossing: New Horizons, Hades, and Luigi’s Mansion 3 all have their die-hard supporters and vocal detractors. The Switch library is deep, and the arguments over what belongs in the top ten are endless.

The Verdict: Why “Best Switch Games of All Time” Will Always Be Controversial

Here’s the truth: there’s no single list of the best Switch games of all time that will satisfy everyone. The Switch’s diverse library means that what’s a masterpiece to one player is a disappointment to another. Whether you crave open-world adventures, tactical battles, party chaos, or serene island life, the Switch has something for you—and something to argue about. So before you declare your favorite the “best ever,” remember: the debate is what keeps gaming interesting.

Ready to start your own debate? Share this post, sound off in the comments, and let the world know which Switch game deserves the crown. And if you’re looking for more Switch recommendations, check out this in-depth list of the best Nintendo Switch games for 2025 for even more hot takes and hidden gems here.